A dedicated reader, tracked me down via email to shed some light on Dog Bone Soup …
I made [it] for several years in some of our "poor" days, soup from any bone I was able to get. The type of bone determined the flavor and ingredients. Ham bone – lentils. Chicken or turkey- noodle. Beef – vegetable.
In the depression era or even just a family having a hard time of it for any reason would go to the butcher and ask for a bone for their dog. The butcher would wrap the bone as he would any cut of meat and the woman or child would be spared the humiliation or embarrassment of having the neighbors see what they had received. There was no cost back then for the bones and usually quite a bit meat left on them that would of course boil off and make a good soup base. To that a wife would add what vegetables she had been able to get. Sometimes they also would come as discards from the green grocer. Sometimes the bones were used over and over ’til the was no flavor left.
- Theresa
Her story got me thinking about my original post and the sorties I was told about food rations and hard times. So, I set out to try and recreate Dog Bone soup.
My first stop was the butcher at the local grocery story. I rang the bell and explained what I was trying to do. He said he still had "dog bones" and given what I planned, he recommended he cut them into 6" lengths. They are now called marrow bones and they are not free. I asked for 2. They were $0.99/lb and the total was 2.89 lbs. Given the resulting size of my batch of soup, one bone would have been more than enough.
I then tracked down dry lentils and the fresh vegetables. I went with the mirepoix as my starting point (1lb carrots, 1 head celery, and large onion). Again, I got more than I needed – half or even a third would be enough.
Back in the kitchen, I chopped up the carrots, celery, and onion. I had a small piece of fatback in the refrigerator so I tossed that into my one pot and cooked out a small amount of fat and then tossed in the mirepoix. I cooked them on medium high heat so they browned a little (rather than the conventional sweating on low heat). I then moved the vegetables to a large bowl and put the bones and approximately 6 cups of water in the pot and brought it to a boil before turning it back to simmer for an hour.
I scooped out the bones and any large bits that were in the stock but I did not strain it. I then added 2 lbs of dried lentils. Yes, again, more than I needed and had I made the corresponding reductions previously mentioned, a single 1lb bag would have been right. I brought the stock to a boil and then simmered for an hour.
I added the mirepoix to the lentils and stock and spiced to taste. I then let it sit on the stove over night to cool down slowly and let the flavors meld. In the morning, my first reaction was "too much soup" so I removed about half into plastic containers for freezing. I then added 4 cups of water.
There was still something missing. Theresa’s note had the answer – "a wife would add what vegetables she had been able to get. Sometimes they also would come as discards from the green grocer". I scrounged through the refrigerator and found the but ends of two tomatoes and a head of romaine lettuce. I chopped up the tomato and the outer leaves of the lettuce and tossed them into the soup while bringing it back to a boil. I also added a small amount of dark brown roux – more for flavor than thickening.
The soup is as close to what I remember as I would hope. I probably have just a bit too much fat in the soup. The fatback helped with the vegetables but the combination of that fat and what came off the bones may be a bit too much. Still, it’s probably accurate.
Thanks to Theresa and my mom for help bringing this recipe back to life for me. A special thanks to Ann for introducing it to me in the first place !
Postfix: the soup goes great with the heal ends from a loaf of multi-fiber bread